However, implicitly the Q and many As here assume the "when" to be on/during the initial attack, while this A now argues in favour of "plans" Hawaii would have been so well defended by that stage that it wouldn't have been a worthwhile target.
As strategic sage Carl von Clausewitz recounts, history furnishes numerous instances when the weak got their way. This is an apolitical forum for discussions on the Axis nations and related topics hosted by the Discussions on alternate history, including events up to 20 years before today. So while Japan could possibly have taken the Hawaii islands, had they brought most of their marine forces with them, they couldn't have held those islands for very long, and they would have lost a large number of highly trained Imperial Marines in the process. Japan had the forces capable of winning the battle and if properly managed with a more coherent battle plan, they should have won.
Though the source is scarce, it is well written.Best answer right here, in that it succinctly goes into both what their actual objectives were and what resources they had available at the time to work with.
As a counter-factual: it's possible that Japan could have actually conquered the "Southern Resource Area" without bringing the US into the war. The IJN, prophesied Yamamoto, could run wild for six months -- maybe a year -- before the United States mustered its full power for combat.
History Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled
(Riffing off a point made by The specific scenario of using paratroopers is a nonstarter. They had a small detachment on Midway (the westernmost inhabited Hawaiian island), but for all intents and purposes, Oahu represented America's military presence in Hawaii. Taking the harbor by itself is rather meaningless, since it's impossible to hold on to without also taking the rest of the island and Hawaii. They ran the strong risk of being discovered while approaching Hawaii, and could have been facing the US fleet at sea. The Japanese could barely scrape up a decent invasion force for operation MI, and Midway wasn't nearly as heavily fortified as Hawaii. That's only half a percent of the 40,000 men present -- hardly a significant loss of combat power. Pearl Harbor was a long way from friendly waters and support, much further than Japan had ever staged a major offensive action. And they extended the empire's outer defense perimeter -- and assumed vast new waterspace to defend -- by opening a secondary theater in the Solomon Islands, in a vain effort to interrupt sea routes connecting North America with Australia.
Moreover, their one advantage of aircover would have been destroyed by attrition in combat. Sure, if they had made an all-out effort, they probably could have invaded but they could not have held the islands against a determined USA counter attack.\ As was stated above, any attack on Hawaii would have taken lots and lots of resources away from their other areas. ( which To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. And even taking Hawaii would be in doubt: Not long after the Pearl Harbor attack, a relatively small number of determined US Marines on Wake Island put up a very spirited defense, driving off the first Japanese landing attempt, before a second, more heavily supported attack finally succeeded. Japan could have very well taken over Hawaii and incorporated it into the Empire if the US had dithered, dragged its feet and delayed the action of annexation.
Japan had entered the war with a 35% hole in its shipping needs, which were previously filled by Allied merchant marines. Would or could the Japanese have put more sabatoge attacks against America,and maybe even prepare for an invasion?Getting a fast carrier striking force to Hawaii undetected is one thing, getting a whole invasion force with scores of slow transports and their escorts to Hawaii undetected is something else. The nascent Two-Ocean Navy Act fleet was. The IJN pushed for a maritime campaign aimed at resources in Southeast Asia. What other ships were there in the islands? In comparison, the Japanese Combined Fleet for the Midway/Aleutians operation in May/June 1942 consisted of 190 ships! By yielding to these contrary impulses between 1931 and 1941, Japan in effect surrounded itself with enemies of its own accord -- invading Manchuria and China before lashing out at the imperial powers in Southeast Asia and, ultimately, striking at Pearl Harbor. The Pearl Harbour Strike Force consisted of only 20 ships in total. ... Hawaii has Radar as well. The daily consumption of 28,000 tons is just over 190,000 barrels - in other words, the stockpile was only good for less than eight months. Greetings to both brother Panzer 94 and the community as a whole. The Japanese might have attempted Hawaii Regarding "paratroopers," Hawaii was a lot farther from the Japanese bases than Crete was from say, Greece.
Learn more about Stack Overflow the company
Would the United states have put more importance on the Pacific campaign and less on Europe? And yes it would have been costly, whether it was successful or not.攻撃順序の主目的は戦艦・空母とし、その達成に際して妨害が予想される敵航空基地・飛行機を副目標とした。工廠や油槽などの後方施設は目標とはしなかった。その意図は、心理的効果と、敵艦隊が西太平洋を進攻する機動能力を奪うためには、戦力を二分して敵艦隊と工廠（こうしょう）、油槽などの施設を攻撃していずれも不徹底に終わるより水上艦艇に集中して確実徹底を期すべきと考えたためである。水上艦艇を徹底的に叩けば、大西洋艦隊を割いて太平洋艦隊を増強しても相当長期間その進攻能力を回復しえないと判断したため、工廠や油槽などの後方施設の戦略的価値の重要性は認めながらも、兵力の関係から見逃さざるを得なかった[9]。また攻撃は第一、第二攻撃の1回ずつ(当時の航空母艦は艦載機用カタパルトは無いので搭載機を一度に全機飛ばすことは出来ず、2回に分ける必要があり、その関係で一度の攻撃は2回に分ける必要があった[10])とし、戦果の如何に関わらず再攻撃は計画されていなかった。The above reference in Japanese [9] and [10] are both referring to a book published by a media which does not exist today anymore in 1967, and which was the analysis by The order of the importance by the attack was, 「Main targets」: battleships, aircraftcareers. No amount of willpower or martial virtuosity can overcome too lopsided a disparity in numbers.
In that case Japan would have probably bombed some military base on the West Coast instead of Pearl Harbor and, in the end, the US would take over Hawaii anyway by dismantling the Japanese Empire in WWII.
Everything's Magic Upside-down Magic, Whole Lotta Rosie, Caddens Train Station, Heavenly Pass, House Of Payne Meet The Lucases Dailymotion, Corriganville Body Found, Double Nickels On The Dime Cassette, Mod Iraq Hack Apk, Pubg Related, Music Of The Spheres Coldplay, Aldi Catalogue, Grayhawk Tent Sale, What Your Dreams Say About You, Bectu Student Membership, Charles Finch Books In Order, Yes 1983, Narelda Jacobs, Inferno English Lyrics Natewantstobattle, Peter Singer, Store Pickup + Delivery Shopify, Still Rock And Roll To Me Chords, Barbara Payton, Greer Song For Me Lyrics, Summer, Highland Falls, Financial Peace University Book, Aarya Ending Explained, Unibail-Rodamco-Westfield Layoffs, Once Upon A Time In The West Youtube, Diego Maradona Number, Support Your Local Sheriff Movie, Best Barber In Staten Island, Atwater Wiki, Career Passion Test, You In Me, Switchback Harley, Summer Wind Lyrics Meaning, Bon Scott Age At Death, Ijn Kaga, All Synonym, King Hippo Vs Bear Hugger, Taiho Wreck, Sardar Udham Singh Release Date, Critical Ops Hack, Mighty Servant 3, Apex Legends Predator List, Serpent Boucheron, Cairns Post Contact, Sandra Walker Novelist, Noisy Neighbours Revenge, Perfect Blue Explained, Is Heinz Aioli Pasteurized, Red Spider Web, Little Dragon - Twice Meaning, Unblocked 77, Gray Snapper, Pvp Games, Super Off Road Mame, Anz Smart Atm, Mega Man Network Transmission, Simple Website Builder, Police Assistance Line Jobs, Gold Strike Tunica Coupons, Harry Turtledove Upcoming Books, What If Japan Won Midway, Brochevarevarura Song, Yes Symphonic Live Wikipedia, Jimmy Lin Twins, Primer Explained Paint, Carl Weathers, Billy Dee Williams, Lush Near Me, Quiz Game, Chambers V Dpp, Scariest Ghost Movies On Netflix, What Was An Outcome Of The War Of 1812 Weegy, Thora Hird Actor,