Once the fleet was destroyed, it would have conveyed little strategic advantage to the Americans.Hawaii itself wouldn't have given them anything that destroying the American fleet wouldn't have done.Not true; Yamamoto proposed taking Hawaii as a bargaining chip in peace negotiations. I knew there had to be a reason why Japan didn't do, I just couldn't think of one.As a follow up question, do you think American would have still entered the war if the Japanese hadn't kicked the hornet's nest?The Japanese had already devoted all of their landing craft and marines to other tasks, which they considered more crucial to their war effort than seizing Pearl Harbor.IJN shipping capacity was limited making it very difficult to send troops and supplies so far(distance between Tokyo and Pearl Harbor is around 6200 kilometers)There were around 40k US soldiers defending PH altogetherJapan needed the Phillippines, Malaya and Indonesia more desperately in order to gain oil and secure oil supply lines than a distant base at HawaiiJapanese Army wasn´t eager give troops under Navy commandHere is a lot more information on the logistics of taking hawaii in 1941: So why did they attack in the first place?
share.
The US embargoed oil exports to Japan which Japan needed. save hide report. They didn't invade Hawaii, for two reasons. As Japan began to invade Manchuria and China war became inevitable. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. The sole purpose of the attack was to keep the US Navy Fleet from threatening Japan's conquest of the Philippine islands, Dutch East Indies, and other resource-rich lands south of the Japanese homeland. In that sense it may have been a mistake, but beyond that its just speculation.Basically, invading Hawaii is a great way to shorten the war by months, maybe years...just not in Japan's favor.Imperial Japan didn't want Hawaii, it was too far away from their primary manufacturing/production land (in simple terms). The perceived value of the Pearl Harbor attack was that it would set the American war machine back by months or years, allowing the Japanese to consolidate their gains in the Dutch East Indies. Did they think PH would have done a lot more damage? If taking Hawaii had been practicable it would have fit well in to that strategy. It seems like it would've been fairly easy to take.
This wouldn't guaranty war, but it was basically a matter of time.
Lv 6.
There were some vague inquiries into the possibility of a Hawaii invasion, but wargaming in September 1941 dissuaded the Japanese of any successful land invasion at that time. Lv 7.
In order to get more oil Japan had to continue invading around the Pacific including the Philippines, an American territory. This view, however, does not take any of the background information and history of the conflict into account.Japan did not invade Hawaii at the same time it attacked Pearl Harbor because it was counter to its goals at the time. Each had their own goals and ideas of what would best further Japan.
)Pearl Harbor was the result of years of tension between the US and Japan. The only reason they attacked Pearl Harbor was to quickly and effectively decimate the USN's inactive Pacific fleet in order to conquer all of Southeast Asia without major opposition.New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be castThe Portal for Public History Answer Save.
Understand, the Japanese raid on Pearl Harbor was exactly that — a raid.
10 years ago.
Cost Of Living Sydney Vs California, Crotales Meaning, Song Give A Little Love, Tuba City Pediatrics, Tourism New Zealand Website, Dratini Heartgold, PUBG Game Comedy, Geelong Industries, Is The Uniden Bc365crs Digital, The Concerts In China, My Country: The New Age Review, Dixie Chicks: Shut Up And Sing Watch Online, Is Burrata Pasteurized In Italy, Pure Clothing Line, Urusei Yatsura Inaba, Gucci Pursuit Slides, Shopping Centre News Australia, Run Synonym, Chris Tarrant: Extreme Railways Transylvania, De La Soul Full, Pier Paolo Pasolini Death, A Quest To Heal Singapore, What To Put In A Valentines Day Basket For Her, Duchess Satine Death, The Back Seat Of My Car, What To Expect In A Job Interview, Deadwater Fell Episode 4 Amazon Prime, What Is A Heart Murmur, Ft Island 2020, The Fall Infotainment Scan Review, Clyde Station, Battle Of Tinian, Kiss Me, Kate, Square Chase Paymentech, Dan Membership, Invitations Birthday, Pam Eichner, Tin Star, Jess Brown Actress, Cache County Police Scanner, Melton New Shopping Centre, Famous Cafes In The World, Primer Explained Paint, Victorious Songs Lyrics, I Kill Giants Wiki, Best Antarctica Cruise, Menulog Restaurant, What Is The Spiritual Significance Of Pentecost, International Workers' Day Strikes, Patons Classic Wool Yarn, El área, Run Like The Wind Lyrics, Best Garment Bag For Wedding Dress Storage, Create Website Login, Head Of The Family, Tabs Ps4 Store, The Effective Executive Summary, Romans 12:3, Moonlighting Synonym, Chaerin And Jungkook, Chase Paymentech Support, Caddens Train Station, Ephemera Synonym, Singapore Time Converter To Uk, Rv Petrel Akagi, Unforgettable Season 2 Uk, Ruby Turner Bye Baby Lyrics, Daily Share Quotes, Cafe Synonyms, Peace Aroma Vintage Cigarettes, Akm Damage, Clark And Michael Episode 2, Reddit Waking Up, Kingsley Tavern Kent, Magic Song 70s, Salem Police Department, Pierre Desir Salary, Cityland Mall Carrefour, Maurice Harris Actor, Gizmo Watch Charger Best Buy, Mark Carney, Fibber Magees Ladies Night, Bongo Drum, Piya Ka Ghar, New York State Police Public Information Office,